Pumpkinseed will amaze you with their beautiful colors. They do not grow as big as bluegill, but they are nice to look at and they are very aggressive. They prefer slack water in ponds, lakes and some streams. They feed on insects, worms and tiny bait fish. Everything we cover in our sunfish section as far as catching sunfish will work with pumpkinseed. You will often catch some pumpkinseed mixed in with other sunfish, but at times, you may find an entire school of pumpkinseed. They taste great too.
Best Sunfish Baits
Nightcrawlers
Nightcrawlers are larger worms, so most of the time, you are going to be using smaller pieces of these worms when targeting sunfish. They can easily grab an entire nightcrawler, but go with the smaller pieces to consistently catch sunfish.
Red Worms
Red worms are much smaller worms and they are the perfect size for most panfish and they are great for sunfish too.
Leeches
Leeches can be very good baits for sunfish, especially if you are targeting bigger fish. The smaller leeches will do the trick. If you are fishing for lots of bites and not necessarily targeting bigger fish, try cutting the leeches into pieces. You can freeze them this way and only use what you need while on the water.
Bread
Bread is a very good bait for sunfish, however, it’s hard to keep it on the hook. Most anglers will chum with bread and then catch the bluegill with other baits, but if you can get the bread to stay on the hook long enough, you can catch plenty of sunfish with a small piece of bread.
Corn
Corn is actually a very good sunfish bait. Just rig a couple of kernels on a single hook weightless and cast it out near your favorite sunfish spot and hang on.
Spikes
Spikes are perfect in size for sunfish and sunfish like to eat them. Use them on a single hook or tip your jigs, spoons and spinners with them to get more bites.
Wax Worms
Wax worms are also a very good size for sunfish. They work great on a single hook, but most anglers use them to tip their jigs, spoons or spinners.
Soft Plastics
There are a variety of small soft plastics that are made specifically for targeting sunfish. If you are in a pinch though, you can rip a tiny piece of soft plastics from your bigger baits to use them as bait for catching sunfish.
Hair Jigs
Hair jigs are one of the better baits for sunfish. Some of these hair jigs are too big for the sunfish to eat the whole jig, however, it doesn’t matter, because you are using the hair jig as an attractor to your bait. Tip these hair jigs with a tiny piece of worm and sunfish will come up and eat the piece of worm. It can be very effective.
Jigging Spoons
Jigging spoons are used for deeper water and they can be used as an attractor also. You will catch some sunfish without tipping these spoons, but you will catch a ton more by tipping the hooks with a tiny piece of worm.
